Thursday, 5 May 2011

V for Vendetta

I would like to start by saying, I really like the film V for Vendetta, however just because a film is enjoyable doesn't mean that it is a good graphic novel adaptation. As shown in this interveiw with Alan Moore (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QX7ehbE1vc0) The Graphic Novel of V for Vendetta was Moore's Ode to anarchy, detailing all of his beilefs on anarchy and facism ect and his response to Margaret Thatcher's administration.The plot of both revolves around an anarchist known only as V and his plot to take down the facist government that is in power and Evey, a girl who has been rescued by and acompanies V.

As with alot of adaptations, the film makers change a number changes to the story when adapting the source material. In the graphic novel V is a cold, emotionless mastermind who is always five steps a head of the government and who's only goal is only to create his "Better World" however in the movie he is a kind, pleasent, revenge fueled terrorist who is thoughtout the film only on par with the government and has a deep love and caring for Evey. Of course this treatment isn't reserved simply to V, in the graphic novel Moore goes out of his way to depict the Government officals as ordinary and sometimes even likable people, in the movie most are nothing more than a cartoonish characture of the nazi party. And possiblly worst of all in the movie Evey is a thirty something ordinary woman, with a good job who is rescued and romanced by V however in the graphic novel she is a sixteen year old who is so poor she is forced to become a prositute to get money and is rescued but then kidnapped and held against her will by V. In the movie she is perfectly willing to help V kill however in the graphic novel she out right refuses. (please see this interesting, if not abit rant-like, article for more differences http://www.scifidimensions.com/Mar06/betrayal.htm) The Movie tamed the story and made it more commerically likable, they removed all the anarchy and endless "shades of grey" and replaced them with romance and clear heroes and villians.

However as I said before i do like the movie, I find it is a good politically driven thriller and this artical (http://uk.comics.ign.com/articles/696/696867p1.html) makes a good point, although different from the graphic novel it is quite appropriate for the time it was made, there are clear references to american,soceity and government, the black bags akin to that from guantanamo bay and the news broadcasters that are alot like their real life american equivilant. The film isn't just some dumb action-thiller that you don't have to think about, it raises a number of policital points and makes a number of interesting comments upon the bush administration and as a film there is very little wrong with it.

But, in my opinion it only works as long as you don't compare it to the graphic novel, as good as the film is, like most adaptations of Alan Moore's work, it proves disapointing once you start to compare it with the source material. This in particluar as it could have been so much better and was tamed down so much. As I said the film is a good and enjoyable one, I can happily watch it again and again, however as an adaptaion I don't think I can call a particularly great one when the point of the story has been altered so much. I don't recommend this film for the top ten.

Monday, 2 May 2011

Ghost World (2001) dir.Terry Zwigoff

Ghost World is a little known adaptation. The graphic novel of the same name told the tale of two teenage girls finding their way in life after leaving high school and realising that their ambitions and hope went necessarily going to come true. It's a real coming of age story and in my opinion on par with the likes of "The Breakfast Club".

The problem faced with this as well as many other adaptations is that if the director was going to make a like for like copy to the original then films would likely last 3 hours and over. For this reason a lot of films make abridged versions of the original work. In Ghost World this is most obvious in the character Seymour, who is a character who was a mixture of various different characters from the graphic novel. What this technique allowed Zwigoff to do is manage multiple story arcs into one nicely packaged whole.

I believe due to its clever way of compositing the whole story together as well at the accolades it has received (it has made comic book film top lists from IGN, Empire and more) that it is a film in need to be archived in a list such as ours.

Ghost World Excerpt:

The Dark Knight (2008) dir.Christopher Nolan

The Dark Knight (2008) is a adaptation of the popular Batman franchise that has been revolutionised by Nolan with his remarkable take on the characters within. Nolans dark style and incredible scriptwriting made it stick out from previous attempts to put the franchise into a film.

Nolan took the story of this from various subplots from the Batman: The Long Halloween set of comics, as with a lot of films based off comic books it's very hard to write something that can contain every single plot choice that the original piece did. Also then again would we want to we already have the comics as a account of how it was originally ment to be seen. Also from a creative point of view as a director you wouldn't want a carbon copy that you cant put your own twist on. This is a adaptation, someone elses interpretation of the characters its not simply a version of the same story.

Because of this nolan truly must be one of the masters of this because of how creative he was with his character development giving these characters new life and possibly adding something needed to them to work in a film context.

Due to this and the critical acclaim it has received it should be put in any archive of graphic novel adaptations.


The Dark Knight Trailer:

Tuesday, 5 April 2011

Watchmen

Okay, so i thought I'd start with one of my favorite adaptations, "Watchmen". Now I think this is a pretty good adaptation, a lot of it is as if it's straight from the graphic novel (Here's a nice little video Illustrating my point: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ONqFE1x23w ) But It still remains new and interesting to those familiar with the graphic novel. I mean the only bad points I can see is that A) It seemed to be advertised as an action movie (One of the trailers: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E4blSrZvPhU ) when the majority of the plot is about morality est, and B), one or two parts were left out and the ending was changed, however you're always gonna need to shorten the story when adapting it to a movie, when interviewed by About.com ( http://movies.about.com/od/watchmen/a/watchmen072807.htm ) Director Zack Snyder said:

People have labeled Watchmen as unfilmable. How hard is it to make Alan Moore's story into a feature film?
 
“The truth is the graphic novel as a verbatim shot-for-shot version, is that filmable? Of course it’s filmable. It’s a six and a half hour movie. You can do that. Is there anyone who will pay the $200,000,000 to do that? Probably not. My job is to try and distill the movie down. Like I say, we’re not inventing anything. We’re just trying to get the movie [to a decent length]. The script’s still 140 pages long. It’s not like a flimsy little document. It’s not a brochure - it’s fricking phonebook.”  



And to be honest although the ending is different in one aspect, It doesn't really make any difference, the  main point and key events of the films final scenes are still the same, the point of the film is still intact. 

I feel this is a film that could certainly make into our Top 10 movie adaptations.